Top Ten Pie Places

Top Ten Pie Places

During the holiday season, everyone loves to have a nice slice of pie. However, not everyone can make pies and store-bought pie doesn’t quite cut it. That’s why we have a list of places where you can pick up some great pie. We hope that this makes the holiday season a little bit more manageable for you.

Buckhead Diner

The Buckhead Diner is a great place to get American comfort food. While this includes burgers, grilled cheese sandwiches, and fried chicken, it also includes their award winning white chocolate banana cream pie. It is something many people have to get if they are in the area. So if you are near Buckhead Diner, make sure you grab some their banana cream pie. There is also a lot more that Buckhead Diner has to offer. So check it out. It won’t disappoint you.

Crave Pie Studio

Crave Pie Studio is one of the best places to get a one-of-a-kind pie. Their store serves artisan, dessert pies made with seasonal ingredients that are perfect for parties, weddings, and events. So if you are hosting a holiday party and have your hands full dealing with everything else, this is the place to go. They will be sure to give you a pie that will have all of your friends and family wondering where you got it. So if you need to impress and don’t have the time or skills, check out crave pie studio.

Joy Café

The Joy Café is a very cozy place to eat at. It’s a great place to just relax for a while. They serve the basics such as sandwiches, salads & brunch. However, you also need to try out their pie. It is said that their cookies and milk pie is to die for and has been voted as one of the best pies in Atlanta. It combines a childhood favorite, dunking cookies into milk, with pie. It is a wonderful combination that will have you reminiscing. Therefore, you definitely need to grab a piece of their pie, if you are ever around.

Mary Mac’s Tea Room

Mary’s Mac’s Tea Room has been around for over 70 years, and it doesn’t seem to be going anywhere. This shop features southern style comfort food in a space that makes you feel right at home. Their menu is very vast, so you can fine several different pies for you to try. Their dessert pies are key lime pie and pecan pie. However, you can also get their tomato pie as one of your sides. Or you can even try their chicken pot pie too. Which ever one you choose, it will have that southern taste we all know and love.

Panbury’s Pies

Panbury’s has such a large assortment of pies that you will have a hard time deciding which one you want. They have pies from South African, British & Australian. They also have savory pies, sweet pies, soups, salads, sausage rolls, mini-pies and hand-pies. Just seeing all of the choices will make you wish that you can try them all. Therefore, in order to fulfill that you wish, you need to get started soon. So head down to Panbury’s as soon as you can.

Southern Sweets

Southern Sweets is one of the best places to satisfy your sweet tooth. They have a large assortment pastries, cakes, cookies, and of course pies. Their pies are baked fresh and ready to go. They use fresh ingredients in sure your sweet is always the best. Many people say to try either their apple, cherry, or sweet potatoe pies. However, you don’t have to go their just for sweets. Southern Sweets also serves classic breakfast foods, soups & sandwiches. They have everything you need, so check it out.

Sugar Shack

The Sugar Shack is a quaint little shop that sells desserts and coffee, plus sandwiches & salads. It also features a little patio area where you can relax while you are enjoying your meal. While they have a variety of desserts, some of their best is the pie. They have several kinds to choice. However, a seasonal favorite is their sweet potato and pumpkin pies. If you’re not in the mood for those, they have even more for you to choose from like their chocolate cream or apple pies.

The Pie Hole

The Pie Hole is located in Roswell. It may not look like much at first glance, but you should never judge a book by its cover. The Pie Hole is in rustic, barn-like space that has a couple of outdoor tables. It has a southern charm to it, and their pies definitely have the southern taste. There are many pies to choose from, like their caramel apple pie or their Derby. Just know that whether you choice, it will be your new favorite pie. So be prepared to see pie in a different way.

The Pie Shop

The Pie Shop believes that “Pie is Love,” and that’s why they make sure that there is a pie for everyone in any season. The Pie Shop makes over 100 different flavors of pie, and their menu changes each month. One of the customers’ favorite flavor is the Pie Shop’s blackberry pie. So it is doesn’t something to try. Also the Pie Shop has another special feature for customers. They offer baking classes. So if you want to learn how to make a certain pie or just pie in general, you might want to sign up for a few of their classes.

The Silver Skillet

While the Silver Skillet can be consider old-school, its food has never gone out of style. The Silver Skillet shows southern hospitality at its finest. And while the furniture may be vintage, the food still taste delicious. You can go in there to get some country-fried chicken, but you have to make sure to try their famous lemon icebox pie. It has been a favorite for years to many customers. That’s why you should also try it while you can.


Didn’t see your favorite restaurant on the list? Check out our Twitter and let us know which restaurants we missed. Or visit us on Facebook and leave a comment if you’d like to see more lists for different areas in the Atlanta area!

If you liked this post, check out these:

CulinaryLocal Top 50 Restaurants

Top 10 Hunting Season

Please follow and like us:

Jerrica is a senior content editor with CulinaryLocal and a recent graduate from Brigham Young University in Utah. She loves books and is very crafty. Her favorite quote is “Books! The greatest weapons in the world. Arm yourselves!”

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Enter to win FREE tickets to a local drink event or experience